Cheryl Craigie’s latest release, a reinterpretation of Taylor Swift’s ‘I’m Only Me When I’m With You,‘ highlights her talent for reshaping a song while staying true to its essence. Released on January 22, 2025, this version trades the upbeat energy of Swift’s 2006 original for a tender, introspective ballad. By slowing the tempo and accentuating the song’s emotional weight, Cheryl delivers a rendition that feels intimate and deeply sincere, like a heartfelt exchange between close souls. Her fresh approach brings a new depth to the track, blending nostalgia with a renewed sense of meaning.
A seasoned singer-songwriter from Woburn, MA, Cheryl Craigie has always created music that speaks to the soul. Singing since childhood, she has cultivated a passion for writing original songs that explore themes of love and life with raw emotion. Her journey has led her to co-produce eight songs with Eric Goldberg, including three original compositions. Cheryl’s versatility is a defining strength, effortlessly weaving elements of folk, rock, country, and even rap into her work. With this latest release, she further establishes herself as an artist unafraid to push boundaries, reinvent familiar melodies, and showcase her authentic voice.
The delicate piano arrangement and unhurried tempo of I’m Only Me When I’m With You add a newfound maturity to the track, making it feel both fresh and deeply personal. Cheryl’s warm, expressive vocals guide the song with precision, capturing its emotional essence with effortless grace. Her interpretation brings a more introspective and heartfelt dimension to the lyrics, offering a contrast to the upbeat vibrancy of the original. Every note is carefully placed, and her impeccable vocal control creates an atmosphere of softness and sincerity, drawing listeners in as if they were experiencing the song for the first time.
Cheryl’s choice to reinterpret a Taylor Swift song, one originally penned when Swift was just 13, reflects her keen ability to uncover hidden emotional depth in music. By slowing down the track and infusing it with her artistic vision, she transforms it into something deeply moving. As Cheryl herself has shared, she wanted to take the song in a new direction, and the result is a rendition that feels mature and profoundly resonant. What was once a youthful, pop-driven anthem of love and self-discovery now unfolds as a tender ballad about identity and human connection, revealing layers of emotion that may have gone unnoticed before.
This track highlights Cheryl Craigie’s ever-evolving artistry, demonstrating her knack for reimagining a song while preserving its essence. Her rendition of I’m Only Me When I’m With You is captivating, showcasing her ability to infuse music with raw emotion and universal relatability. Once again, she proves her talent for creating deeply resonant pieces that connect with listeners on a personal level. With this cover, she not only pays tribute to Taylor Swift’s songwriting but also reinforces her distinctive presence in the music industry. If this release is any indication, Cheryl’s future work promises to be just as heartfelt and meticulously crafted, establishing her as an artist to watch.
Connect to Cheryl Craigie on Spotify and YouTube